Understanding Aphantasia and Visual Imagination

— Rob Perin

Aphantasia and the Mind's Eye: What It Is and What It Means

Close your eyes and picture a red apple on a table. Can you see it? Maybe it's as clear as a photo. Maybe it's a fuzzy shape that fades the moment you look at it. Or maybe there's nothing to see at all, just the idea of an apple.

If your answer was "nothing," you're in good company. Roughly one person in a hundred or so has little or no mental imagery, and many of them don't find out until they're adults. They hear a friend say "picture a quiet beach" and assume it's just a figure of speech. Then someone explains that other people really do see the beach, and the whole conversation changes.

That experience has a name: aphantasia. This post explains what it is, where the idea came from, what researchers have learned so far, and what it does and doesn't mean for your memory, your creativity, and even hypnosis. At the end, you can take our free Mind's Eye Test to find out where you fall.

What is aphantasia?

Aphantasia is having little or no voluntary mental imagery. Ask someone with aphantasia to picture a sunset or a friend's face, and they know the facts about it. They know the sky goes orange and their friend has brown eyes. They just don't see a picture in their head when they think about it.

The word comes from the Greek phantasia, a term Aristotle used for the mind's ability to produce images. Add the "a" at the front and you get "without phantasia." The opposite end of the scale is hyperphantasia: mental images so vivid they feel almost like real seeing.

It's worth saying clearly: aphantasia is not an illness, and neither is hyperphantasia. Both are normal differences in how a mind works. Many people with aphantasia remember facts and feelings very well, think easily in words and ideas, and do well in all kinds of work.

A short history: from a breakfast table to a name

People noticed this difference long before anyone had a word for it. In 1880, the Victorian scientist Francis Galton asked people to picture their breakfast table that morning and describe how clear the image was. Some saw it in rich detail, with color and light. Others, as Galton reported, had no power of visualizing at all.

Then, for well over a century, the topic mostly sat quiet.

It came back because of a single patient. Neurologist Adam Zeman at the University of Exeter met a man who had lost his ability to visualize after a heart procedure. Zeman went looking for earlier research on this and found surprisingly little. Then, after news stories about the case, other people began contacting him to say they had never been able to visualize in the first place.

In 2015, Zeman and his colleagues Michaela Dewar and Sergio Della Sala published a study of 21 people who described a lifelong lack of voluntary imagery. They called it congenital aphantasia. The name stuck, and research has grown quickly since.

How common is it?

It depends a bit on how you draw the line, but it's more common than most people expect.

Early estimates from Zeman's group put total absence of imagery at around 0.7 percent of people, with a larger group having weaker imagery. More recently, an international study of more than 3,000 people estimated about 1.2 percent have aphantasia, 3 percent have dim imagery (called hypophantasia), nearly 90 percent fall in the typical range, and about 6 percent have hyperphantasia.

So depending on the study, somewhere between one in a hundred and one in thirty people sits at the low end. If you work in an office of a few hundred people, you've almost certainly met someone with aphantasia. They may not know it themselves.

It's a scale, not an on/off switch

Mental imagery isn't something you either have or don't. It runs along a scale:

  • Aphantasia: little or no mental imagery.
  • Hypophantasia: dim, faint, or fleeting images that are hard to hold.
  • Typical imagery: clear but not lifelike. Most people live here.
  • Vivid imagery: bright, detailed pictures that come easily.
  • Hyperphantasia: images as vivid as real life.

The other thing people often miss is that imagery isn't only visual. You can imagine a song, the feel of warm sand, the taste of a lemon, or the smell of coffee. Research suggests these senses can vary independently. In a large survey from Australia, a broader lack of imagery in other senses showed up in some people with aphantasia, but not all. One person may see nothing and still "hear" a favorite song perfectly. Another may have a quiet mind in every sense. That's why a good test looks at more than just sight.

What aphantasia is not

A few common misunderstandings are worth clearing up.

It's not a lack of imagination. Imagination is much bigger than pictures. You can think through a problem, invent a story, plan a trip, or dream up a design without a single image. Many people with aphantasia do all of those things every day, using words, ideas, patterns, and feelings.

It's not a memory problem in general. Some people with aphantasia do report weaker personal memories (more on that below), but many have excellent memories, especially for facts.

It doesn't mean you never see images. Many people with aphantasia still dream in pictures. In Zeman's survey of about 2,000 people with aphantasia, most reported visual dreams, even though they can't call up a picture on purpose. Voluntary imagery (the kind you summon) and involuntary imagery (the kind that just happens) seem to work differently.

It's not the same as a sudden loss. If your imagery changed quickly after an illness or injury, that's a different situation, and it's worth talking to a doctor.

What the research has found so far

Aphantasia is still a young field, and the findings come with plenty of "it depends." Here are some of the most interesting results.

Imagery can be measured, even if you can't see inside someone's head. Researchers have used a clever visual test called binocular rivalry, where each eye sees a different image. For most people, imagining one of the images beforehand nudges which one they see. In one study, people with aphantasia showed almost no such effect, which backs up what they say about their own minds.

Imagery seems to turn up the volume on emotion. In a 2021 experiment, 22 people with aphantasia and 24 people with typical imagery read frightening stories while their skin response was measured. The typical group's skin response climbed as the stories went on. In the aphantasia group, it stayed nearly flat. But when both groups looked at actual scary pictures, they reacted about the same. So it wasn't that people with aphantasia feel less in general. Imagined scenes just seem to hit them with less force. The researchers noted these are averages, and not everyone with aphantasia will match.

Imagery may help with remembering and planning. People with aphantasia in the large Australian survey described their personal memories and imagined futures as less vivid and rich in detail. They reported dreaming less often, too. Interestingly, their reported spatial abilities, like finding their way around, were on par with everyone else's. A later lab study backed up the memory finding, showing that recalling the past and imagining the future came with fewer rich details.

It runs in families. Zeman's work found that aphantasia shows up in relatives more often than chance would predict, which hints at a genetic piece, though surroundings almost certainly play a part too.

Some people find faces hard. People with aphantasia reported more trouble recognizing faces than the other groups did, though not everyone does.

Keep one caution in mind. Nearly all of this research relies on people describing their own experience, plus some clever lab tasks. Nobody can look into another person's mind and check. That's one reason the field keeps moving, and why the numbers shift from study to study.

Aphantasia and creativity

Here's where many people expect a catch: if you can't picture things, can you be creative?

Yes. Zeman's survey found that aphantasia was linked with scientific and mathematical jobs, while hyperphantasia was linked with creative professions. That's an association across thousands of people, not a rule about any one person.

And the examples go well beyond science. Ed Catmull, co-founder of Pixar and a leader behind some of the most visually inspired films ever made, has said his mind's eye is blind. He worked out something was different when a friend asked him to picture a sphere and he couldn't. Blake Ross, a co-creator of the Firefox browser, wrote a widely shared 2016 essay about discovering at age 30 that other people could do something he couldn't.

So the takeaway isn't that aphantasia helps or hurts creativity. It's that creative work can run on many different engines: words, rhythm, structure, concepts, movement, and feeling.

A note on acquired aphantasia

Most people with aphantasia have had it all their lives. But imagery can also change later, such as after a stroke, head injury, or surgery. That was the case with the patient who started Zeman's research. If your ability to picture things changes suddenly, check in with a doctor.

Aphantasia and hypnosis

This is a question we hear a lot: "I can't picture anything. Can hypnosis still work for me?"

Yes. Hypnosis doesn't depend on pictures. It's built on attention, words, and suggestion. If you can follow a voice and an idea, you can follow a hypnotic suggestion, whether or not you see anything.

Many hypnosis scripts do lean on visuals, like walking down a staircase or lying on a beach, and that's the root of the worry. But a skilled hypnotherapist simply uses whatever works best for you:

  • Words and sound. The voice itself, its rhythm, and the ideas it carries.
  • Body feelings. Warmth, heaviness, lightness, and breathing are powerful routes into relaxation, and they don't need a single image.
  • Taste and smell. Some people who see nothing can still almost taste a lemon. Our Lemon Test is a quick way to feel how strongly your body answers your imagination.

In practice, "picture a quiet beach" just becomes "notice the warmth spreading across your shoulders." The suggestion changes, but the goal stays the same.

The same goes for guided meditation and self-hypnosis. If a script says "visualize a white light" and nothing happens, that's not a failure on your part. Try swapping in a feeling, a sound, or a plain idea instead.

Practical tips if you think you have aphantasia

If any of this sounds like you, here are a few friendly ideas:

  • Lean on your strongest senses. If sound, touch, or movement come more easily than pictures, build learning and relaxation around them.
  • Use words and structure. Lists, outlines, stories, and simple mnemonics can do the job pictures do for other people.
  • Ask what others mean. When someone says "see it in your mind," ask what they actually experience. Comparing notes is often how people first realize their minds differ.
  • Don't treat it as a flaw. It's a difference, and many people with aphantasia say they wouldn't trade it.

Where do you fall?

Reading about imagery is one thing. Finding out how your mind works is more fun.

The free Mind's Eye Test has 28 questions and takes about six minutes. It looks at how vividly you can imagine with sight, sound, touch, taste, and smell, shows where you fall from aphantasia to hyperphantasia, and checks for signs of synesthesia, where one sense sets off another. There's no sign-up, and your result is written for your exact answers, not pulled from a form letter.

It's designed for curiosity and self-understanding, not diagnosis. Whatever you score, every point on the scale is normal.

Take the free Mind's Eye Test →

If you enjoy it, you might also like our Focus & Trance State Profile or the Kappasinian Suggestibility Test, which look at other sides of how your mind works.

Sources

  • Galton, Francis. "Statistics of Mental Imagery." Mind 5, no. 19 (1880): 301–18.
  • Zeman, Adam, Michaela Dewar, and Sergio Della Sala. "Lives without Imagery: Congenital Aphantasia." Cortex 73 (2015): 378–80.
  • Zeman, Adam, Fraser Milton, Sergio Della Sala, Michaela Dewar, and others. "Phantasia: The Psychological Significance of Lifelong Visual Imagery Vividness Extremes." Cortex 130 (2020): 426–40.
  • Keogh, Rebecca, and Joel Pearson. "The Blind Mind: No Sensory Visual Imagery in Aphantasia." Cortex 105 (2018): 53–60.
  • Dawes, Alexei J., Rebecca Keogh, Thomas Andrillon, and Joel Pearson. "A Cognitive Profile of Multi-Sensory Imagery, Memory and Dreaming in Aphantasia." Scientific Reports 10 (2020): 10022.
  • Dawes, Alexei J., Rebecca Keogh, Sarah Robuck, and Joel Pearson. "Memories with a Blind Mind: Remembering the Past and Imagining the Future with Aphantasia." Cognition 227 (2022): 105192.
  • Wicken, Marcus, Rebecca Keogh, and Joel Pearson. "The Critical Role of Mental Imagery in Human Emotion: Insights from Fear-Based Imagery and Aphantasia." Proceedings of the Royal Society B 288, no. 1946 (2021): 20210267.
  • "An International Estimate of the Prevalence of Differing Visual Imagery Abilities." Frontiers in Psychology (2024). doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1454107
  • Gallagher, James. "Aphantasia: Ex-Pixar Chief Ed Catmull Says 'My Mind's Eye Is Blind.'" BBC News, 2019.
  • Ross, Blake. "Aphantasia: How It Feels to Be Blind in Your Mind." Facebook note, 2016.
  • Hypnotechs. Mind's Eye Test.

Free test

How do you take suggestion?

Take the free Kappasinian Suggestibility test to find out whether you respond more to literal or inferred suggestions, with a personalized result.

Take the free test → or browse all free tests

Rob Perin, CCHT

Hypnotechs Hypnotherapy & Hypnosis

Keep reading